Challenging the Odds: The Implications of Playing for a Low-Performing High School Softball Team on College Recruitment

Allen Goodwin • April 4, 2025

This is a subtitle for your new post

Challenging the Odds: The Implications of Playing for a Low-Performing High School Softball Team on College Recruitment


At Legacy & Legends Softball, we receive numerous emails daily with many being questions about the recruiting process. One of the most popular questions is regarding how important is a high school softball program when it comes to a player's recruitment. Depending on who you ask, the responses will vary on this sensitive topic. Many travel ball programs will state it is the travel ball team that gets a player recruited and many high school programs will claim their programs set the foundation for a player's academic advancement to college towards being a student-athlete. Nonetheless, a high school program who is afforded so much time with a player can either help develop and foster good habits or unfortunately, possibly allow bad habits to form.


From my experience as both a high school and travel ball coach, I see that both play a significant part in the recruitment process, especially when considering if a player wants to play for a Division I or Division II or a Division III program or even a junior college team.  If you actually count the hours spent on softball at a high school and hours spent with coaches in travel ball, you will see that a player spends a significant amount of time with their high school softball program and in many if not most cases, they spend less time with their travel ball program.  From preseason preparation, to in-season competition, to off-season sessions ... many if not most players will spend more time with their high school program if that program is actively promoting a competitive softball environment. Albeit high school may take more time, it is ultimately the travel ball team that typically will dictate whether a player moves on to play at the collegiate level and on what type of program.


Since a majority of time is spent may be spent with high school coaches (almost daily during the school year in locations where high school softball is deemed very important) the program can either help or hurt the player's growth and development.  This will be a factor in many facets including, strength and conditioning, on the field and game skillsets, character traits and conduct, game IQ, and overall mental and physical development.


Playing for a low performance high school softball team can significantly affect the recruitment perspectives of the university, mainly due to three interconnected factors: exhibition, level of competence and personal development. These factors interact in a complex way, ultimately influencing the visibility and attraction of a player towards university programs.


Exposure is often promoted as a critical element in the recruitment process for any sport, including softball. Athletes who play in high performance teams (both travel and high school) generally receive more attention from university scouts and coaches simply because they participate in competitive tournaments and show events that attract the largest public and the coverage of the media. On the contrary, low performance team players may not have the same level of visibility, particularly if the team does not participate in high level competitions or attend showcases where university recruiters are present. Without correct exposure, even talented athletes could have difficulty gaining the necessary attention to ensure university sports opportunities.


The level of competition facing athletes is another significant factor that affects recruitment. High performance teams (both high school and travel ball) generally play against equally skilled opponents (typically playoffs for high school), creating an environment in which players can improve their skills and adapt to the challenging game. This level of competition can help athletes develop better skills and consciousness of the game, traits that university coaches actively seek. In contrast, players in low performance teams or playing in considered weak leagues or conferences, may not have the same opportunity to overcome their limits or face regularly formidable opponents. This lack of competition could lead to stagnation in skills development, which potentially makes them less attractive to university programs that prioritize athletes that can prosper in high pressure scenarios.


In addition, personal development through coaching, teamwork and individual training can affect recruitment. Coaches in high performance programs, both high school and travel ball, often have more experience and resources to help players improve, both technically and mentally. They can provide constructive criticisms that are essential for growth, while the dynamics of a competitive team environment encourages players to raise their performance and fight for excellence. On the contrary, low performance teams can have difficulty providing this type of support, potentially delaying the development of players that could otherwise excel in different circumstances. The use of less qualified training or lack of access to specialized training facilities can hinder the progression of a player and, by extension, her recruitment perspectives.


Despite these challenges, it is crucial to recognize that playing in a low performance team is not entirely harmful to the recruitment perspectives of a player. Personal determination, work ethics and the ability to show improvement can significantly mitigate the disadvantages of playing at a lower level. Many athletes have successfully gone from programs less visible to higher levels of competition by participating in complementary "private lessons" training, attending exhibitions independently or participating in travel leagues that offer a better exposure. Personal ambition can promote an athlete to develop skills and build a recruiting profile that captivates recruiters, regardless of the success of their high school.


In conclusion, while playing for a low performance high school softball team, it presents clear disadvantages related to exposure, competition and personal development, it is not irrevocably to athletes that recruitment opportunities are lost. Personal initiative, the effective use of independent training resources/private coaching lessons, and adaptability can help athletes to position themselves for success, even in the absence of a prestigious team. As such, the impact of low performance team is a multifaceted topic that covers challenges and opportunities, underlining the importance of inherent talent and proactive effort in the search for collegiate athletic opportunities.


Simply put, grow and blossom where you are planted. Always seek opportunities to challenge yourself to make yourself better and all those around better because of your presence and efforts. Leave the team and the team environment a better place when you leave because of your efforts and impact. It is because of your actions at both your high school and travel ball that will shape and play a key factor in where you end up playing in college should you so choose to do so. Attitude is everything ... both positive and negative.

Fortune favors the bold.


By Allen Goodwin, Legacy & Legends Softball, 4 April 2025




By Allen Goodwin April 16, 2025
Name: Jaeden Antonelli Nickname: Jay Hometown: Whippany, New Jersey (NJ) Grad Year: 2027 GPA: 4.0 Travel Team: Team Pennsylvania-Augustus 18U High School: Whippany Park High School Positions: Shortstop (SS), Outfield (OF) Height: 5’7’ Bat/Throw: Right/Right Overhand Velocity: 64 mph Exit Velocity off Tee: 75 mph Home to First or 20 yds: 2.795 Laser Timed Intended Study Major: Computer Science Email: jaeden.antonelli.2027@gmail.com Twitter: @Jaeden_2027 
By Emily Jackson March 31, 2025
Chasing the Dream: How Softball Players Pursue College Scholarships
By Allen Goodwin March 20, 2025
Travel softball teams have become very popular in recent years. Many families are enthusiastic about the possibility that their children play at a higher level and compete against other talented players. However, being part of a travel team has serious commitments that parents and players must understand before jumping. One of the biggest things to think about is the commitment of time. Travel teams often have an intense program, with practices, games and tournaments almost every weekend. This can take a long time even during the week, as players must attend regularly to improve their skills. Parents should consider if their child can manage this level of commitment while keeping with school, friends and family responsibilities. Another important part to think about is the financial commitment. Travel teams can be expensive. Parents must be foreseen not only for team taxes, which often cover uniforms, coaching and other expenses, but also for travel expenses such as gas, hotel stays and food during tournaments. The tournament commissions can add quickly and these costs may vary significantly from one team to another. According to Mireie et al. (2021), families should have a clear understanding of all the costs involved before making a decision. It is essential for parents to evaluate the readiness of their children for this commitment. Some children thrive in competitive sports, while others may feel overwhelmed by pressure and time requests. Parents should have open conversations with their children on their interests and goals. It is essential to determine if the child really wants to pursue travel softball or if they feel they get along with what others expect. When examining the travel teams, parents should also consider the priorities of their family. Each family has different resources, which can affect the fact that they can afford the costs and times necessary for travel softball. It is important that parents evaluate these factors against their daily commitments. In this way, families can guarantee that being part of a travel team adapts to their general plan without causing stress or conflicts. The choice of a travel team is a great decision and involves a thought attentive to several factors. Parents must think about their child's ability to manage the occupied program that is provided with travel softball considering also what will cost. The key is to make sure that this commitment is in line with the lifestyle of the family and the financial situation, without sacrificing the happiness or well-being of the child. Regarding softball teams, the quality of coaches and the development of players are very important factors to consider in parents. A good coach can make a big difference in player skills development and character development as a person. Coaches not only need to know the game well, but they should also be able to teach these skills in a way that helps players learn effectively. According to Lehman et al. (2019), having qualified coaches can have a considerable impact on the growth of a player, on and off the field. The coaches are more than simply teaching softball; They also play a key role in building a positive team environment. When coaches provide constructive comments, players learn to improve their performance while strengthening self-confidence and resilience. This type of atmosphere of support allows young athletes to learn from their mistakes without feeling discouraged. In addition, major coaches encourage teamwork and sports spirit, which are essential for the personal development of a player. Choosing a travel softball team with experienced and competent coaches is crucial. Parents should seek teams that prioritize player growth and development and keep their coaches responsible for their teaching methods. An environment led by effective coaches helps players to develop not only their sporting skills but also important life skills. A coach will create and foster the environment a player will be in. Therefore, it is very important to find a coach who can create and foster a healthy learning and training environment to ensure the best opportunities for your child to grow, develop, and enjoy travel ball. It should also be noted that there are important differences between the competitive game and the recreational leagues. Competitive leagues often require a higher level of engagement and skills, focusing on victory and performance. Although it can be exciting, it can also cause pressure for young players. On the other hand, the recreational leagues tend to focus on the participation and pleasure of the game. They offer a more relaxed framework, allowing young athletes to learn sport at their own pace without the intense pressure of the competition. Whatever the type of league, it is important for parents to choose a team culture that promotes healthy comments and positive interactions between players and coaches (Trussell, 2016). A good coach will promote open communication, making sure that players feel safe to share their thoughts and concerns. Creating a culture of respect and encouragement leads to stronger links within the team, allowing young athletes to prosper as players and peers. The quality of coaching and the environment in which players develop are key factors that can strongly influence a child's experience in travel softball. Ensure that a team has qualified coaches who prioritize individual growth and team dynamics can make all the difference in the journey of a young athlete, enrich their experience and their level of competence in sport. Parents should actively look for these qualities when placing travel softball teams for their children., When you consider the travel softball teams, parents must think about the impact of the competitive game on the general well-being of their child. While many young athletes like the excitement of competitions, high-level performance pressures can lead to stress and anxiety. This stress can affect them both emotionally and physically. High level competition often means more practices, games and travel. As competition increases, the pressure to succeed too. Young athletes may think that they must be perfectly performed or risk dropping their team. This feeling can create a lot of anxiety and fear of failure. This can also lead to professional exhaustion, where the athlete can lose interest in the sport they once loved. Parents should prioritize the mental health of their child and make sure that playing travel softball remains pleasant. It is essential to keep the emphasis on pleasure and learning instead of simply winning. Encourage children to set personal goals, to celebrate small achievements and to enjoy their time with teammates can help to create a positive experience. When victory becomes the only objective, the pleasure of playing can decrease, which means that sport feels like a chore rather than a joy. Each child is different and they will manage competition in their own way. Some may thrive under pressure, while others may feel overwhelmed. Parents must monitor signs of stress, such as behavioral changes, increased anxiety or loss of motivation. Open communication is essential; Parents should encourage their children to express what they think of their participation in sport. Another important aspect is the commitment required for travel softball. The large travel schedule can lead to fatigue, lack family activities or time with friends. Parents should help their children balance sports with other life activities, such as academics, social events and downtime. When children feel well balanced and are not too committed, they are often happier and more successful in their activities, including sports. In addition, parents should be involved in discussions on the quality of coaching. Good coaches not only teach skills but also promote a healthy team environment. They prioritize the well-being of players and encourage a positive attitude towards competition. Understanding coach styles and their impact on young athletes can help parents choose the right team. Overall, the objective of participating in travel softball should be to develop skills, promote teamwork and take advantage of the game. Parents play a crucial role to ensure that sport remains a source of happiness and growth for their children. Supporting their mental health, keeping communication open and encouraging a balanced lifestyle can help protect young athletes from the negative effects of high competition. By focusing on these aspects, parents can ensure that their child's experience in travel softball is enriching and fulfilling. By: Allen Goodwin, Legacy & Legends Softball, 20 March 2025 www.legacyandlegendssoftball.com Citations: Lehman, Sharon M., Christopher R. Schmidt, and Jennifer L. Livingston. THE YOUTH SPORT SEXPERIENCES OF COLLEGIATE SOFTBALL ATHLETES. Journal of Behavioral & Social Sciences 6.4 (2019). Mirehie, Mona, et al. Towards an understanding of family travel decision-making processes in the context of youth sport tourism. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management 21 (2021): 100644. Trussell, Dawn E. Young people's perspectives of parent volunteerism in community youth sport. Sport Management Review 19.3 (2016): 332-342.